Small Business Debt (and What It Really Does to You)

Most people talk about the risk of owning a small business like it’s a scoreboard problem:

“What if you don’t make money?”

That’s real. But it’s not the quiet thing that keeps founders awake at 2:17 a.m.

The darker, unspoken reality is debt.

Not the abstract concept of leverage you read about in finance books. The kind of debt that shows up every month, on schedule, with zero interest in how your pipeline feels, how your customers behave, or whether your team had a rough quarter.

Debt is often the true weight of entrepreneurship and small business ownership whether you started from scratch or entered through Entrepreneurship Through Acquisition (ETA).

And if we’re being honest: debt doesn’t just sit on the balance sheet.

It sits on your nervous system.

Why Small Business Owners End Up Here

Here’s what makes small business debt different from the “startup story” that gets all the media oxygen:

Most small business owners don’t have access to meaningful equity funding.

No VC rounds. No “pre-seed.” No safety net of investors who are underwriting risk as part of their model.

So founders do what the real economy does: they borrow.

That borrowing can come from a bunch of places:

• Conventional bank loans
• SBA-guaranteed loans
• Seller notes (especially common in ETA)
• Lines of credit
• Friends & family loans
• Personal guarantees that follow you home

And it’s not hard to understand why this happens.

Debt can create the growth capital you’d otherwise never touch.

Debt can help you buy a business, hire key talent, expand capacity, invest in systems, or survive a down period long enough to recover.

Debt can be a catalyst.

But debt is also a constraint, especially when the economy gets uncertain.

Debt Doesn’t Just Impact the Business. It Impacts the Humans.

This is the part that doesn’t show up in the spreadsheets.

Debt can create mental health pressure. It can create tension inside a marriage. It can create conflict between business partners. It can create a low-grade stress that never fully turns off.

Why?

Because debt isn’t just math; it’s interpretation.

Two people can look at the exact same debt load and feel two very different things:

• One person feels energized (“We’re building something big.”)
• Another person feels trapped (“We’re one bad quarter away from disaster.”)

Neither is wrong. They’re just carrying different emotional realities.

And the higher the leverage, the more that gap matters.

Debt can expose fault lines you didn’t know existed.

The Real Fork in the Road: Where Free Cash Flow Goes

Once a business starts generating real free cash flow, founders like to imagine it goes one place:

growth.

But in practice, free cash flow usually goes to one of three places:

1. Growth (the fun answer)
2. Owner income (the necessary answer)
3. Deleveraging (the reality for many owners)

This third bucket is where a lot of founders quietly live, especially in the seasons where the business is stable but the future is uncertain.

And that’s where an important reframing comes in:

Deleveraging isn’t always a retreat. Sometimes it’s the strategy.

The Paradox: Deleveraging Can Be the Best Growth Strategy

Over time, many businesses accumulate meaningful debt, often in the pursuit of scale.

A couple million dollars of leverage isn’t unusual for a small business that has:

• acquired another company
• expanded headcount
• built infrastructure
• invested in systems
• weathered a downturn

The problem is: once the debt is there, growth gets harder, not easier.

Because the payments don’t care about your ambitions.

So what happens when uncertainty rises, economy softens, demand volatility increases, or slower sales cycles?

In those moments, becoming more conservative for a season can be a power move.

If the timing is right, a couple years of deleveraging during uncertain times can:

• reduce stress on the organization
• create operational breathing room
• protect your team from panic decisions
• open up future borrowing capacity
• position you to seize opportunities later (when others are stuck)

This is the founder version of playing long-term chess instead of short-term checkers.

You’re not shrinking.

You’re reloading.

“What’s the Optimal Debt Load?” The Truth: There’s No Exact Equation.

Founders often ask the same question:

“How much debt is too much?”

The honest answer is: there isn’t one universal formula.

The “right” debt load depends on things like:

• cash flow consistency
• customer concentration
• gross margin profile
• working capital needs
• seasonality
• sales cycle length
• your ability to cut costs quickly if needed
• your personal tolerance for risk

A debt structure that’s healthy for one business can be deadly for another.

So instead of searching for a perfect number, I think founders should aim for something more practical:

A debt load that preserves options.

If the debt removes your ability to make good decisions, it’s too much even if the math technically works.

A Practical Playbook Before You Take On Debt

If you’re considering debt regardless if it’s an SBA, conventional, personal, and friends & family loan, don’t run it like an optimist.

Run it like an operator.

 Here’s what that looks like.

1) Build a Real Operating Plan

Not vibes. Not “we’ll grow into it.”

Build an Annual Operating Plan (AOP) that ties together:

• revenue assumptions
• gross margin expectations
• headcount and comp
• operating expenses
• cash flow timing
• debt service requirements

2) Create a 12–24 Month Cash Forecast

Profit doesn’t pay loans. Cash does.

A cash forecast shows you the timing reality of:

• payroll
• tax payments
• customer collections
• vendor payments
• loan payments

3) Stress Test the Bad Stuff

This is the part founders skip because it feels negative.

But it’s not negative. It’s responsible.

Stress test scenarios like:

• revenue down 10%
• revenue down 20%
• slower collections
• churn spikes
• margin compression
• sales cycle extends by 30–60 days

Then ask: what operational changes would we need to make to still cover debt service?

If the plan requires miracles, the debt is telling you the truth.

4) Keep Relationships with Multiple Bankers

Talk to bankers consistently, and talk to more than one.

Different institutions see risk differently. Market perspective changes. Terms change.

That perspective can give you something founders desperately need when leverage rises:

peace of mind through optionality.

5) Don’t Guess; Model It with a Fractional CFO for Small Businesses

If this isn’t your core strength, don’t wing it.

Bring in a financial professional or fractional CFO to run FP&A around:

• debt service coverage
• liquidity buffers
• covenant headroom
• downside scenarios
• deleveraging timelines

You’re not buying spreadsheets.

You’re buying clarity.

Debt Isn’t Bad. But It’s Not Neutral.

I’ve always believed debt can be a good thing, when it’s done optimally.

Debt can create leverage. It can accelerate a business. It can open doors that would otherwise stay shut.

But debt amplifies everything:

• your upside
• your downside
• your stress
• your relationships
• your decision-making posture

It’s not for the faint of heart.

And the worst part is that many founders carry it silently, like they’re the only one who feels the weight.

You’re not.

The Closing Question

If you’re a founder or operator:

What decision have you made (or avoided) because your debt load changed your tolerance for risk?

And if you’re staring at a debt decision right now, here’s a simple thought:

Don’t just ask, “Can we get the loan?”

Ask, “What will this loan do to our options, our sleep, and our ability to lead in uncertainty?”

Because that’s the part nobody puts in the pitch deck.

Key Takeaways

• Emotional Weight: Debt is more than a financial metric; it creates psychological pressure that impacts decision-making and leadership.
• Flexibility vs. Certainty: High leverage forces founders to prioritize certainty over innovation, shrinking the margin for error.
• Strategic Deleveraging: Reducing debt during uncertain economic times can be a "power move" that creates future operational breathing room.
• No Universal Formula: The "right" debt load is unique to every business and should be measured by whether it preserves or removes options.
• Operational Rigor: Before borrowing, founders should use an Annual Operating Plan (AOP), cash forecasts, and stress tests to model downside scenarios.
  

Frequently Asked Questions